You can’t really say 10ft/lbs of torque is better then 10HP… one reason is because HP is a fictional number made up from an equation using the torque numbers and RPM… this is why hondas can get away with having 100ft/lbs of torque and still make 200HP… cause they rev to the sky.
I hate saying this, cause it’s my default answer, but to answer your question… it comes down to what you are looking for, as to wether or not XXX setup is worth losing XXX driveability.
well to start of HP is not a real number…it is derived from your torque number…so depending on the gain of or loss of torque will determine the gain or loss of hp…usually if u gain a significant amount of HP u are also gaining torque