Loan to a CD? what am I missing?

Okay.
What am I missing here.
I talked with friends and my parents about this one.
They all say there’s a catch why you can’t do it.
But they don’t know what it is.
So uhm… hlap?

My Credit Union offers a loan at 4.45% APR.
Loan is whatever in the hell you want to do with it.

So, Why can’t you take out a loan with it, say… a Five year loan at 4.45%
Then, they also offer a 1 Year CD at 5.10%…

So, why can’t you take out a loan, Put it in a CD, then use the CD after it matures to pay off the loan?

You’ll have to make monthly payments out of pocket I assume, yeah…
But you’ll end up getting that back at the end of the year.

What am i missing? =S

I think I’m kinda stupid. lol.

you’re not missing anything.

On $1000 principal:

pay $0.12/day interest to the loan.
earn $0.14/day on the CD, plus compounding.

It works so long as the loan is simple interest (not actuarial), and has no prepayment fee.

Its not uncommon at all.

So that would technically work?
Only downside being I wouldn’t be able to take out another loan if I need to?

But at .02 a day it’s not worth it at all.

Yeah, at only $1000…
It’s free money though o.O

I can go with a longer CD with higher %…
Hmm.

However that is only 7 bucks…

Okay, don’t do this unless you have some very preferential rates.

Let me break it down:

On $1000, you’ll pay $18.67/mo for 12 months.
Come month 13 of the loan, remaining principal owed will be $802.12
You’ll have paid $41.73 in interest.

If you close the CD you’ll have $1,052.21
Pay off the principal of the loan @ $802.12
You’ll have $250.09 in your pocket. This is NOT WHAT YOU PROFITED

$250.09 - 197.88 (principal paid) - 41.73 (int paid) = $10.48 profit.

Not the brightest move. You’re basically opening a savings account with a interest rate of 1.10% APY.

Just so you realize what you’re talking about:
If you had put the $1000 (no loan) into a regular savings account (daily compounding) @ 4.25% APY (a very common rate right now), it would’ve taken you 89 days to earn $10.68 in profit.

Hmm, I see I see.
good call :]
Thanks, lol.

Well.
I have an account at bank of america… My savings account there is at .2%
She said the highest I could ever get with bank of america is a business account and that would be .25%
So I wasn’t really sure what to do.
Online I saw 5.05% and such, but I’m not really sure how safe those kind of bank accounts are.

Thanks a bunch, lol.

The low interest loan and stuff was through a Credit Union, not Bank of America.
The Credit Union I rarely do anything with. The Saving account I have there is 1.19% APY

HSBC & M&T Bank are both large local banking companies and they are both offering “online” savings accounts which pay more then 4.00% APY, daily compounding, with no fees or minimum balances.

They are more then safe. FDIC insurance upto $100k.

“Online” simply means that there is no overhead for the bank to pay on these accounts. You open them online, print a form, sign it, mail/fax it in. Voila.
Overhead meaning: the bank did not have to pay a teller to sell you the account; pay an account rep to sit down & chat with you for an hour; pay for the electricity for you to be able to sign the paperwork (which they also pay for) in the warm lighting of a branch office; etc…

You CAN STILL ACCESS THE ACCOUNT VIA WEB & TELEPHONE & BRANCH banking.

:slight_smile:

oh, and on $1000 for 1yr, daily compounding:

0.02% = $2.00 profit
4.25% = $42.50 profit

awesome.
thanks =]

I have a hsbc direct account with a few grand in it.

You dont make alot on interest unless you have serious money in there.

Even at 4.25 your just keeping up with inflation the way the dollar is sinking.