Intel vs AMD

This more pertains to integrated graphics. Assume 4g of SSD2 RAM.

which is a more preferable solution:
Intel with the 4500 integrated graphics accelerator
AMD with the 3200 ATI Radeon integrated unit

both processors would be 2.0-2.4ghz

I do no gaming whatsoever, the occational DVD watching, office-type documentation, pdf files, research, so nothing graphics intensive

an aside: if i have 3d rendered anatomy programs, is a stand alone GPU a better idea?

not going to make any difference man

AMD if youre forcing yourself into integrated video.

The Intel 4500 is very, very poor. The AMD 3200 is only very poor. The margins are very minimal here, however.

I would never consider using either of them in a computer for any purpose, whatsoever.

Your average $50 video card will outperform them many times over. Then you wont be struggling to play youtube ‘HD’ videos.

Stand alone GPU is always a better idea,I’d say it wouldn’t be worth it if you were just doing basic computing,being that you mention 3D rending I’d say its worth it.

But that’s not really a AMD vs Intel Debate,more of a onboard vs card debate.

AMD seems like they’re back on track with processors now,according to the toms hardware benchmarks.

i wouldnt be doing the rendering persay, but the programs i have avalible to me have pretty cool layering features ect, and i dont know how graphically intense that is.

you’re going to want an onboard card.

Get the Intel, since their processors run circles around AMD these days, then take the $25 hit to pick up something like this. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814125251

forgive me, im not very tech savvy…
if the motherboard has an integrated graphics card, what does that do when an external GPU is installed? I suppose I would much rather pick up a laptop with a card already in it, drivers installed ect

You just disable the onboard video when you add a real video card in it.

I assume you’re looking at laptop integrated graphics… MHD4500 is going to perform very poor, like ZOMGVTEK said, and Radeon 3200 is still poor but significantly better, so go with that.

yeah like i said, im trying to just address my needs with a computer. i started out wanting every feature possible, but then i realized i probably need less than what im looking at. haha WAY too many toys out there to have

and to reiterate… 0 gaming. the most complicated thing it might do is a 3d anatomy program with layering

GOT IT!
Thank God haha. I was freaking out about it but finally pulled the trigger and am very happy. With the coupon i was well under my 1000 price line, and i tacked on a total coverage 3 yr with accident protection warranty. I was having an issue with coupons not being stackable with online discounts… this 250 off 1099.00 was stackable so it worked out great. :slight_smile:

Your customized PC includes:

  • HP Pavilion dv3z Entertainment PC
  • Genuine Windows Vista Home Premium with Service Pack 1 (64-bit)
  • AMD Turion™ X2 Ultra Dual-Core Mobile Processor ZM-84 (2.3GHz, L2 Cache)
  • 4GB DDR2 System Memory (2 Dimm)
  • 500GB 5400RPM SATA Hard Drive with HP ProtectSmart Hard Drive Protection
  • ATI Radeon™ HD 3200 Graphics with 64MB Display Cache Memory
  • 13.3" diagonal WXGA High-Definition HP LED BrightView Widescreen Display (1280 x 800)
  • Slot Load Super Multi 8X DVD+/-R/RW w/Double Layer Support
  • Webcam + Fingerprint Reader
  • Wireless-G Card with Bluetooth
  • Full Size Backlit Keyboard
  • 9 Cell Lithium Ion Battery
  • $10 OFF!! System Recovery DVD with Genuine Windows Vista Home Premium (64-bit)
  • Microsoft® Works 9.0
  • HP Home & Home Office Store in-box envelope

Product description Product # Qty Your
extended
price
HP Pavilion dv3z Entertainment PC FJ745AV 1
$702.99

Summary of discounts for order H106797858:

Instant discounts you received:

$250.00 Coupon NB3984
$150.00 Notebook instant rebate
$70.00 PC+ESP instant rebate
$60.00 PC+ESP instant rebate

NY Tax:
Shipping:
Grand total: $56.24
Free
$759.23

You may receive another e-mail confirming the other portion of your order.

Looks like a similar setup to the HP I got…Looks like a pretty solid machine, nice buy.

i woke up this morning thinking i should have gone with the wireless-n but then i thought i wouldnt ever notice the difference

You can always swap the minipci card out in the laptop, or put an external n card in there if you want it.

Do you already have an N router?

I’m waiting for the N standard to become final before I buy the hardware.

thats why i opted not to get it. i dont have the hardware, and as of now, neither does the school im going to

IT would be dumb to get wireless-n until it is a standard.

There is no point to buy a wireless N router unless you are looking for network coverage.

Anytime someone tells me that G is too slow for thier home internet I want to punch them in the face.

The guy at best buy said G is too slow so it must be true :shrug: