Vacation to the Caribbean.. Recommendations?

If you don’t mind a long ass flight I’ll tell you about my honeymoon on an island in Fiji. I went to a resort only accessible by boat. 12 huts so 24 guests max at any given time. One big central hut for eating, signing up for activities, etc. They beat a wooden drum to call you to lunch and dinner. Only other thing on the island was a village only accessible by boat or walking through a couple miles through a trail through the forest.