Grand Island is weird. very little to do there but plenty of decent homes if you feel like overpaying for them and then over paying for taxes and then paying the cover-charge every time you come and go off the island.
Lewiston isn’t much better minus the cover charge.
When the shit really hits the fan Grand Island has huge defensibility advantages. Move a couple K rails up on the 2 bridges and station a few guys with AR-15’s and you’re protected from all land incursions. Not too hard to get to it by water though.
This is it. If shit really hit the fan, you’re not lasting very long unless you have some crazy ass bunker and a team of archers / snipers to keep people away from your ingress / egress points and vents, etc.
I can’t figure out what typical price/sq ft is anymore but it seems most homes in my area are going for around $200/sq ft. Will be interesting to see where that house you found ends up going for. Ayer connects Maple with Klein, not exactly a neighborhood-like atmosphere which may turn some people off.