Gotta remember, these places are having a hell of a time with insurance. Friends condo had the roof badly damaged last hurricane, insurance wouldn’t cover it, so everyone in the building is paying for the roof. I don’t doubt a lot of these crazy HOA fees are in response to insurance problems.
Problem is 10 minute walk is still going to lose it’s roof in a hurricane. My buddy’s place is more like a 10-15 minute drive and lost his. The inability to get insurance for lots of these places is a huge issue. At the same time, as someone that lives in a geographically stable area where I am very unlikely to suffer a total loss of my home due to natural disaster (wildfire, flood, earthquake, hurricane etc) that still has to buy homeowners I do appreciate companies saying, “This area has too many claims, we can’t afford to keep doing business here without raising everyone’s rates or going out of business”.
The answer will probably be similar to what insurance does with people that want to live in a flood zone. FEMA will need to setup “hurricane zones” and you will be mandated to purchase an additional policy through the government if you live in an area deemed a high risk hurricane zone and want a mortgage, similar to areas deemed flood zones with flood insurance. If it’s a low to zero risk hurricane zone you wouldn’t be forced to buy hurricane insurance, but at the same time your regular homeowners insurance wouldn’t cover hurricane damage (again, the same way homeowners won’t cover you in a flood).
I’ve been casually looking in St John for a few years now. No banks will lend and no insurance will cover anything because it’s pretty much 100% chance the property gets nailed. The only solution is to design a structure that’ll hold up… And that means a dome or shipping container, lol.
“Double the square footage cost” is a bit excessive, lol. My problem wouldn’t be storm surge but wind… And weeks without power or water like the last hurricane. Love to see that we can design homes for 250mph winds though