Yes, retarded and obviously a biased fan.
But, Eli as of last week had the #2 rating in the league including a perfect rating the week before. Sure, question the quality of teams he has faced but how do you explain the Pro Bowl appearance the year before? The Super Bowl ring? The Super Bowl MVP? The playoff appearances years-after-year.
Also, just to remind you as I got a feeling you are a Patriots fanboi: He outplayed Tom Brady and the Giants outplayed the Patriots in the Super Bowl.