Yeah I know, but from a business standpoint the better thing for him to do would be PM.
Here’s why. Suppose someone is just lurking and sees the lower posted price. What if they are looking for another tire, so they use that number and compare Nick’s pricing with a competitor. While yours may be lower for you, Nick’s might be higher for person B and thus he would lose a sale as opposed to gaining 1 and potentially losing 0.
Can we shake hands and drink some beer now?