i think it is a very good idea, only thing I would say is if there was a whole section dedicated to the reviews then have a couple guys be official mods. so all of the reviews would be “official” more or less, and everything would be more organized. so anyone would be able to do a review, but they have to propose their idea to the mod, then get approved/denied. if it gets approved, they do their review, do a writeup, and possibly get checked over real quick by the mod before it gets posted. I’m not talking full on newspaper editorial department, but just a little bit of communication so things don’t get too unorganized.
I feel it should be this way, because while there is an abundance of knowledge on here, there is also those few people who would make a big joke out of it and probably ruin it.