Here is a wild tangent. I was joking with my argument, but I’ll bite anyways. Assuming that the equation is simple:
Happiness = Reality - Expectations
I’d like to take you question a step further, would it raise goals if there were no coping drugs, whether it is use of prescription anti-depressants, alcohol, or illegal narcotics? Coping drugs make things better by either elevating a person’s perception of reality or lowering their expectations. Removing this would mean that a person would need another form of fulfillment: hobbies, internets, art, video games, reading, consumerism, travel, religion OR another form of endorphin release: exercise, over eating, acupuncture, massage, sky diving. Would the reality of these activities meet their expectations? For some yes, for others no, some are good, some are bad. Some people will just be angry, my history is a little hazy, but weren’t there a lot of angry movements around the prohibition era? My perception of Muslim and Mormon society is that they are angry, or maybe just too stern. If a person has a casual drink or smoke does it hurt their long term expectations (goals)? I’d say no. If a person binge drinks 3 times a week or is high the majority of their waking hours does it hurt their long term expectations (goals)? I’d say yes.
I’d think a prohibition would in the short term decrease happiness of those that don’t have other forms of fulfillment.
Quality of life. This was a rebuttal to JayS “less disposable cash” from the McRaise, as in smoking would allow a person to be complacent with the lower quality of life. So the quality of life was dependent on income, not whether or not marijuana was legal. Prohibition in this context would hurt how a person coped with their current quality of life as it removes a coping mechanism.
Another point is we need more “common core”, they aint got no time for unicorns puking rainbows and artsy creative stuff, and therefore expectations will be lowered so happier students… right?
Happiness = Reality - Expectations
Let’s say Lucy is a Happiness -90 = 10 - 100 (low reality and high expectations)
A drug addict is a Happiness 90 = 100 - 10 (perceived reality and low expectations)
Both ends of the spectrum are unhealthy.
Striving hard worker Happiness -10 = 40 - 50 (still has a goal that they are working toward)
Striving hard worker + beer Happiness 5 = 55 - 50 (everything seems better)
Lucky break corp ladder worker Happiness 15 = 75 - 60 (this person might lose motivation)