Heya James,
I added a couple of tires to the list that I recommend that are approximately equal. I can’t get the Toyo unfortunately, sorry. Also, I didn’t quote the KDW NT because I don’t like it 
(It’s got average dry performance and very good wet performance… just not my thing and probably not yours either)
Yokohama S.Drive
255/35/18: $175 per tire
225/40/18: $219 per tire
BFGoodrich G-Force Sport
255/35/18: $168 per tire
225/40/18: $199 per tire
Dunlop Direzza DZ101
255/35/18: $155 per tire
225/40/18: $206 per tire
Falken 452
255/35/18: $158 per tire
225/40/18: $202 per tire