Yea, you mentioned 70 Camaro and every motorhead cop was out to lynch the bastards.
As for the situation, get a motion spotlight on the driveway. Get a Linksys Wireless webcam and set it up to record when the light is triggered or for motion. The camera is +/- $70 and the motion spotlight is $20. So for sub $100, you are done.
I just heard they found your mirrors. There were a bunch of thefts on that street. Supposedly college kids on a scavenger hunt. Garages broken into as well.