jdaniels, a semi-experienced (not necessarily highly educated, though) post begins naow:
This is a video of an STi going 1st through 4th (happens to be a (once?) local 35r car, I just chose this video because it was the first thing that came to mind when I saw this “debate”):
http://www.youtube.com/user/jays05#p/u/15/7xJMf2z0YpI
You have to look/listen HARD for the one-two shift, it’s there though :rofl
Now skateshelter and/or other STis may not have the balls, skills, foot/hand agility, or properly set up car to shift quickly and maintain boost as effectively as the fine gentleman in that video, amplifying the ridiculously short gearing in those cars.
Having been in a local green STi-powertrained car around various curvy roads in Mexico, I can say that this gearing very much reflects the car’s roots and does it VERY well; the STi is of course a rally car by nature. The power and torque are always on tap so any corner from 20mph up can be exited right at 3500-5000rpm or whatever RPM you want to be at.
This does not carry over too well to drag racing, though. Having been in a local STi 1st through 5th racing another local high-teen MPH car, the STi lost ground 1-4 and kept the distance and possibly gained on the car in 5th.
Also having driven the same car, the tq is awesome 1-4 and 5th can certainly be called the “killer” gear, just like 4th is in most turbo hondas (due to traction in the hondas, not gearing like in the subies).
“killer gear” example: ( :rofl )
^just like that car runs train in 4th, STis run train in 5th.
Example of how stupiddddd short 4th gear is in STis (roll on in third, lets out at top of 4th):
You can clearly see that if the car is super laggy and/or shifting isn’t instant, boost will go bye-bye, as will power, and as will the race
Another vid I found, 1st through 6th, car doesn’t look that fast but you can still see how 5th would be money:
/rant