I have to get in this too and say vanek is better. It is not all about scoring goals. Vanek is much better defensive, not power killing good, but much better then Max.
Stealtth is correct, they are totally different players. If i had to pick one, it would be the guy who doesn’t give it away at least once a game… Vanek.
And I truely believe Roy will be the guy in the next couple years.