What final outcome are you looking for?
Site has been “hacked”/compromised and taken advantage off. Person admitted to doing it and reading private messages.
Person was banned and account disabled.
Thread could have been locked from the start as there was no need for discussion on the matter, we were sure we were right enough to make the call.
You’re lucky we even let the person sign back up and tell his side of the story.
But yeah go ahead and yell foul play, as you lose sight of the point of the thread.