3m Tape will outlast a lot of stuff out there today. Problem is no one puts it on the right way. I go through 10ft rolls of double sided 3m tape at work like toilet paper and it has not let me down yet. Be weary of the person putting it on… Not the product.
From what I have read, the issue is the existing urethane residue left behind from the original installation does not allow a full bond for the tape in some areas.
I have cleaned mine 10x and there is still residue left behind.