Are Americans losing touch with DIY skills?

This month’s Popular Mechanics is all about basic DIY skills. I found this article very interesting.

http://www.popularmechanics.com/home_journal/how_to/4221637.html

Science fiction author Robert A. Heinlein once wrote: “A human being should be able to change a diaper, plan an invasion, butcher a hog, conn a ship, design a building, write a sonnet, balance accounts, build a wall, set a bone, comfort the dying, take orders, give orders, cooperate, act alone, solve equations, analyze a new problem, pitch manure, program a computer, cook a tasty meal, fight efficiently, die gallantly. Specialization is for insects.”

That’s a tall order. Although I can only do some of those things, I approve of the principle. Now*adays, though, we’re specializing more. A popular Internet essay is titled: “I Can’t Do One-Quarter of the Things My Father Can.” Are hands-on skills—building things, fixing things, operating machines and so on—really in decline?

I think so. SAT scores provide a record of academic performance, but there’s no equivalent archive for tracking handiness. There is, however, a lot of anecdotal evidence that what used to be taken for granted as ordinary mechanical skills now amounts to something unusual. When I recently wrote on my Web site about the importance of giving kids hands-on toys, a reader e-mailed: “Boy, can I second [your point about] the lack of basic skills in adults. I volunteer with Habitat for Humanity here in Los Angeles. The volunteers who come out frequently can’t do something as basic as using a tape measure. … Many of my Saturdays are effectively clinics on how to pound a nail.”

Even the simplest of automotive tasks, changing a tire, seems to be beyond the ken of many people. According to AAA, nearly 4 million motorists requested roadside assistance last year—for flat tires.

And just look at the Popular Mechanics Boy Mechanic books to see the kinds of skills that boys and teenagers were once routinely expected to possess. These books (which PM published in the early 20th century and recently reissued) assumed that young readers would be prepared to construct a fully rigged ice boat, a toy steam engine, or—I’m not kidding—a homebuilt “Bearcat” roadster powered by a motorcycle engine.

It’s hard to imagine too many teenagers tackling projects of that magnitude these days. To be fair, young people today are likely to have skills that earlier generations never dreamed of—building Web sites, say, or editing digital movies. But manipulating pixels and working with physical materials aren’t quite the same thing.

Does this matter? And if people are becoming less mechanically handy, is that so bad? I think so—and not just because specialization is for insects.
We don’t all have to be MacGyver, but from time to time all of us will face problems that can’t be addressed with a laptop and a cellphone. In a genuine emergency, having some basic manual skills could be the difference between surviving comfortably and being totally helpless.

I think that a modicum of ability in dealing with the physical world is good even for those of us whose jobs are mostly cerebral. Engineer Vannevar Bush, one of the great minds of the 20th century, made his mark on everything from the Manhattan Project to the development of computers. But when he wasn’t commanding vast enterprises, Bush spent a lot of time in his basement workshop building things. He said that trying to make a finished project match his blueprints taught him humility and problem solving.

Shop classes and the Boy Scouts used to teach a lot of real-world skills, but both have faded under the onslaught of budget cuts and shifting political winds. (Shop isn’t just for boys: My wife took shop in high school, and is glad she did.) The traditional father-son route for teaching these skills has also weakened, as many fathers lack the requisite skills themselves, and others, because of divorce, don’t have as much opportunity.

I don’t think the decline in hands-on skills is irreversible. In fact, it might be starting to turn around. The boom in home reno*vation has led many people to brush up their DIY chops. Home Depot and other retailers are finding success offering workshops in basic techniques.

We’re also seeing changes in our popular culture. One example is the best-selling status of The Dangerous Book for Boys, by the brothers Conn and Hal Iggulden. It hearkens back to the Boy Scout manuals and *other boys’ books of the early 20th century, with instructions on how to build go-karts, bows and arrows, rafts and more. The book’s success tells me people are interested in regaining lost ground. (It works, too: I gave my 8-year-old nephew a copy, and it got him away from the Xbox and into the outdoors.)

Conn Iggulden tells me he hopes the book inspires fathers to get out in the yard with their sons to build catapults and the like. “Most boys will value something they do with their dad, and they’ll have an experience they’ll value for the rest of their lives,” he says. “If you show them how to beat the next level on the Xbox, it won’t last the rest of their lives.”

We can start with our own families, but there’s no reason to stop there. Most people can do more than they think they can, and it’s often fear of failure as much as lack of skill that keeps people from tackling hands-on tasks. So the next time you see somebody by the side of the road, waiting for AAA, pull over and show them how to use a tire iron. Who knows? It just might catch on.

The issue also had a list of 25 skills every man should have.
http://www.popularmechanics.com/blogs/technology_news/4221635.html

1. Patch a radiator hose
2. Protect your computer
3. Rescue a boater who has capsized
4. Frame a wall
5. Retouch digital photos
6. Back up a trailer
7. Build a campfire
8. Fix a dead outlet
9. Navigate with a map and compass
10. Use a torque wrench
11. Sharpen a knife
12. Perform CPR
13. Fillet a fish
14. Maneuver a car out of a skid
15. Get a car unstuck
16. Back up data
17. Paint a room
18. Mix concrete
19. Clean a bolt-action rifle
20. Change oil and filter
21. Hook up an HDTV
22. Bleed brakes
23. Paddle a canoe
24. Fix a bike flat
25. Extend your wireless network

I was 25 for 25, except I’m not certified for CPR. I know how though. Sadly after asking around at work today the majority of men couldn’t do more than half. The majority of women couldn’t do more more than a quarter of them.

Never cleaned a bolt action rifle, rescued people from a capsized boat, or performed CPR, I’m certain I could though.

I grew up around both technology and the outdoors. Good mix for sure.

I’ve actually done all but the CPR one.

The boat, and CPR ones havn’t come up. And it’s been awhile but I do remember most of the procedure for a bolt-action.

But thinking on it more, it scares me that quite a few couldn’t even do, or have done half that list.

capsized boaters can go fuck themselves

People have paid me to unpack and set up a new computer system…lol.

A lady in her early 60’s paid me $25 to plug her printer back in and fix the color on her TV.

Those aren’t on the list but its quite scary.

I’ve done 20-22 of those things.

I can do 25/25 I havent performed CPR on someone who needed it, just the dummy when being certified.

I kind of expect the numbers on here to be higher. Car enthusiasts tend to be more DIY.

i cannot or have not done more than half the things on that list, fewer than 10 in fact… and i’m proud of it…

i’d rather be able to handle more advanced concepts and specialise… more money in it.

and you dont get bitches knowing how to fillet a fish damnit.

What about filing points or fixing a vapor locked fuel pump?..well maybe those are outdated.

Some of that stuff like patching a bike tire tube I haven’t done in years. Same goes for cleaning a fish. I can’t quite remember how to do concrete. I think it’s 1 shovel of cement, 2 shovels sand, and 3 shovels gravel.

2. Protect your computer
5. Retouch digital photos
16. Back up data
21. Hook up an HDTV
25. Extend your wireless network

there is nothing manly about any of these tasks. I cant believe someone put them on a list with frame a wall or clean a rifle.

Are Americans losing touch with how to pluralize words?

You guys think you’ve done easy things…

Working at toyota…I had to drive to lancaster with a screwdriver to switch plates from one car to another. the cars were sitting in the driveway next to each other.
The people were too lazy or did not know how to change a set of liscense plates.:loopie:

Things I failed/don’t know how to do on that list:

  1. Is this a trick question?
  2. No (But I know how to find a book to tell me what to do)
  3. Hell No. PHotoshop and I don’t get along.
  4. :uhh:
  5. No. But there are directions on the bag, so I would just read and follow.

I don’t think the “clean bolt action rifle” part is fair. So many states have anti gun laws, many people aren’t exposed to that. Not everyone lives out in the country and can go hunting, or has a sharpshooting team at school. The only reason I know how to do it was because I was trained in the military.

I can honestly say 24/25. Never done CPR. Filleted a fish AND cleaned a Remington .223 this weekend :slight_smile:

But driving a Mustang doesn’t help your cause… j/k :slight_smile:

I can say 21 out of 25. But fixing computers doesn’t seem to fit on the list.

I think the computers thing is on the list because computers are so much a part of everyday life now as opposed to say the 1980s. Kids coming up now need to know basic computer skills, and that includes troubleshooting.

Hey, you’re the one building a kitchen as opposed to cruising down to one of the last big car shows of the year :thankyou:

how come “put a spare tire on” isn’t on that list?

I think the rifle one belongs on there. How many of our dads could do it? What about their dads? And I can’t think of a single state where a basic bolt action .22 isn’t legal.

The funny part is the more urban you get, the more these basic skills are forgotten, or as Bing puts, “not worth anything”. Then something like Katrina comes along, or even our little October storm, and suddenly my ability to write great .Net code isn’t worth much. My ability to re-wire my forced air furnance to run off an extension cord from my neighbors generator is much more valuable.

And there is definitely a link between being able to solve mechanical problems like making a car powered sump pump from an old float switch, an AC inverter and an old pool pump (something I did for a neighbor during the storm) and being able to visualize building a solution to a problem in code. I look at the code I write compared to some of my less handy co-workers and my solutions are far more elegant and complex.

It doesn’t matter if I’m trying to figure out why a car is misfiring or troubleshooting why a section of code isn’t properly handling NSF fees; it’s all the same problem solving structure in my head.

Then there’s the monetary advantage. My old neighbors across the street asked how I can afford all the toys I have. Well, lets see…
Since we bought our house over 5 years ago I have had exactly 2 professionals come here to do work. To install carpet and to snake a sewer line

Things I’ve fixed myself:
Fixed a leaking dishwasher
Replaced a french door with a sliding glass door
Repaired windows
Repaired a garage door
Repaired a gas range
Fixed a leaking garage roof, figured out a bad downspout design caused the leak, and redesigned/rebuilt the downspout so it wouldn’t happen again.
Repaired a washer
Fixed a few plumbling leaks
Fixed countless issues with cars
Installed multiple A/V components, surround sound speakers etc
Replaced some of my landscaping
Installed a new pool liner
Built and installed new roof support pillars on the front of my house
Repaired my snowblower (twice)
Installed a ceiling fan and re-wired the switch to dim the lights while keeping 100% power to the fan.
Replaced a bathroom vent fan that required a shrinking the giant hole from the 30 year old fan to fit the much smaller newer fan.
Replaced a section of concrete sidewalk.
Installed a new laminate floor in the dining room

That’s just what I can think of off the top of my head. Add all that stuff up over 5 years and the savings are probably close to what I paid for my boat. Half of that stuff I had never done before so I read about it and figured it out.