http://www.wben.com/news/fullstory.php?newsid=10399
“I think it’s a responsibility of our business community leadership to get out there and criticize where we have to criticize and applaud where we have to applaud,”
– Carl Paladino, Buffalo businessmanBuffalo, NY (WBEN) - Buffalo real estate developer Carl Paladino is calling for the state to remove the Buffalo School Board, in the latest of a series of paid advertising messages where he presses for city reform and better leadership.
Paladino’s radio advertising, airing on WBEN, minces no words, and is a open letter to the board and Superintendent James Williams, directly calling for them to pay better attention to community needs.
“Hello, Board of Ed and Dr. Williams, can you hear us now?” Paladino says in the messages…“We are still waiting for the state to remove you.”
His criticism focusses on spending issues and the recent scandal involving the suspension of a student at McKinley High School.“You get $26,500 per student. We could send all of them to private schools and have $10,000 left for a college fund,” he says in the open message to the board.
Earlier this year, an independent investigator was hired to conduct an investigation of McKinley High School,after volunteer coach Michelle Stiles questioned whether boys basketball coach James Daye was involved with a student. Principal Crystal Barton fired Stiles and student Jayvonna Kincannon was suspended for 5 weeks when she used a cell phone during school hours to try and speak on Stiles’s behalf.
Paladino’s statement refers to the coach as “the philandering Daye” and questions whether he is worth a $79,000 annual salary.The board citing costs, state education law, and the time considerations involved, has declined to persue disciplinary action against Barton, despite the investigator’s report (below) which says the Kincannon suspension was overly long.
“You couldn’t find the courage to reprimand a rogue principal who slandered, discharged and humliated a talented volunteer coach, and vilified and abused a 15-year -old honor student,” Paladino says in his open message to the board. " You (The board) blatantly showed favoritism toward a … coach… with the feeble excuse that it would be too costly… You should be ashamed of your collective disfunction and overall incompetence."
The Paladino approach, while not always embraced because of it’s bluntness, is generating a range of reactions, including some support for those who want others to speak out more often in favor of reform. A few examples:
Board Member Chris Jacobs, a downtown real estate developer: “I certainly share his frutration on the McKinley incident,” Jacobs says, adding that more public input can improve the school system, as long as it doesn’t degenerate into “character assasination”
“It’s time for taxpayers like Mr. Paladino to make public education an issue in their communities,” says Ralph Hernandez, West District Board member.
" I think more people should express their frustration with dealing with their government," says Dennis Penman, a former chair of the county industrial development agency. “A lot of people acquiesce.”
Two frequent Paladino targets, Buffalo Mayor Byron Brown and Superintendent James Williams, through their spokespeople, declined to comment on his latest in a series of controversial public remarks. In the past, the Buffalo City Council has considered censure of Paladino for outspoken remarks about Williams race. Paladino has often said Brown is unqualified and owes his election to politics not ability.
While Paldino’s candor gains supporters, it does not have universal support. A downtown business person who has worked with city development officials but did not want his name disclosed, tells WBEN that the public route that Paladino choses may not always be as effective as more behind the scenes diplomacy.
Paladino remains unapologetic. " I think it’s a responsibility of our business community leadership to get out there and criticize where we have to criticise and applaud where we have to applaud," he said in an interview with WBEN’s Dave Debo You can hear Debo’s reports and related liveline interviews available on the audio links above right.
This is the kind of guy Buffalo needs to be mayor.