For all the shift Audi fans, to go s4 or no?

My 1.8t GLI rips pretty well but for some reason I just do not enjoy it as much as my old a4. I was thinking s4 simply b/c I’ve already had an a4. However, with already owning an a4, I know wht it takes to make them go & it’s a lot of $. S4 I’d just do an exhaust & tune for a nice toy.