I call BS on that… I bought something from Ebay and it wasnt as described so i put a paypal claim in… I even spoke to paypal on the phone, they froze the funds in his account, but inorder for me to get my money back, i had to send the item back FIRST, then i would get my money back… Thats straight from paypal… I did just that and i got my money back… However, just because you put a claim in, it dosent gaurantee that youll get your money back… And the Fact still remains, he got his money back for the lip, so he should give the lip back exactly how he got it… Hes not out any money… if he got scammed hed still be trying to get his money back, theres no reason to be a dick and fuck the guy over, just give the shit back… i mean the guy even gave the money to cover return shipping