insurance companys fuckin suck....

Did you have any injuries from the accident? Did you miss work? You can most likely dispute the witness, but they may take you to court over it. Depends on how much evidence they have really. It is just an eye-witness account or did the cop actually get the radar on you?
I know if we ever pay back on a claim we only pay back 80% so that it does not mess up your tax’s at the end of the year.