Sti vs. Evo

What would you rather have.

Evo or a Sti.

Pros and cons of both

theres a 04 sti with 65000 on it for 21k (this is at a dealer)

or a 03 evo 8 with 27000 on it for 19.k (this is a private seller)

What would you choose, and what would be cheaper on insurance.

I always liked the evos better, but as of late i want a Sti