what is shifts biggest downfall ?

Maybe for you. Most of the reason you’re seeing a member and post spike are because of:

  1. banned users creating new accounts. Some have gone upwards of three or four accounts.
  2. drama, everyone wants to get their two cents in and make sure their voice is heard.

I’d hardly call that better than ever.

I will keep my opinions to myself other than what I just said, and talk about it solely among other mods/admin.