Who's at fault???

When he said he was a lawyer, I panicked a bit and said I would give him cash. He said how much, and I offered $500. I then proceeded to give him my name, cell number and address (but not my condo apt. number). He said he would call today for the money, but so far I haven’t heard from him. If he does call, I’ll just say I am going through my insurance and that’s that.